**Comment restated:**

I鈥檝e been working with 欧宝体育直播925-A03, *Effects of Lubrication on Gear Surface Distress*. I鈥檝e followed the example calculation in Annex D starting on page 43. I鈥檝e been able to duplicate all the results, with the exception of the last result for 鈥淧robability of wear鈥 on page 48. The result listed is Pwear = 5% or lower.

I鈥檝e been able to duplicate all the numbers that go into the result:

(y) = 0.425354

(muy) = 0.215956

(Sigmay) = 0.112623

and x = ((y-muy)/Sigmay) = 1.859273

These results are calculated per Annex B 鈥 Normal or Gaussian probability. On page 39, under 鈥淓valuation of Q鈥 it states that if the absolute value of x is greater than 1.6448, then Q = 0.05. Since our value for x, 1.859273 is greater than 1.6448, our value for Q is 0.05.

The section goes on to state that if x is greater than 0, then the probability of failure = 1 鈥 Q. Since our value for x is positive, our probability of failure is 1 鈥 .05 = .95 or 95%. This does not agree with the 5% given on page 48.

What am I doing wrong?

**AGMA鈥檚 response:**

After considerable discussion, the Helical Gear Rating Committee concluded that the calculated results of the example problem in annex D of 欧宝体育直播925-A03 are correct. However, there may have been confusion introduced into the document when the reader compares the discussions in annex B, 鈥淣ormal or Gaussian Probability鈥, clause 8.2.2 of the information sheet, and annex D.

To clarify the intent of the example problem, on page 48, where the risk of scuffing and the risk of wear are calculated using the discussion in annex B, the conclusion statements would be clearer if worded as:

- Probability of scuffing failure 鈥 = 5% or lower
- Probability of wear failure 鈥 = 5% or lower

The committee intends to discuss the text related to this subject during their periodic review of the document.